For this blind tasting, we embarked on a journey to discover the best American whiskeys generally disturbed in Utah that is priced under $20, a price point that’s often overlooked but holds some hidden gems. With the lineup of 10 contenders, I conducted two blind taste tests of the whiskeys based on aroma, flavor, finish, and overall balance. Here are the results, from lower-rated to higher-rated whiskeys.
Blind Review Results:
10th Place: Ten High
Utah Price: $9.99
Size: 750ml
High Ten took the last spot, struggling to make a positive impression. The flavor was thin, with a weak finish that didn’t sit well with the tasters. While it may be inexpensive, it’s a whiskey that’s better left on the shelf or used as a mixer.
9th Place: Conciere Whiskey
Utah Price: $15.99
Size: 1000 ml
Conciere Whiskey landed near the bottom due to its weak and somewhat artificial taste. The nose had an odd, almost candy-like quality, and the palate was one-dimensional. It lacked the balance and complexity that we found in the higher-rated whiskeys.
8th Place: Old Overholt Rye Whiskey
Utah Price: $16.99
Size: 750 ml
Old Overholt Rye Whiskey offered a more subdued rye experience. The spice was there, but it was overshadowed by a slightly medicinal taste. The finish was short and not particularly memorable, making this whiskey a less favorable option in this tasting.
7th Place: Jim Beam Bourbon
Utah Price: $19.99
Size: 750 ml
Jim Beam Bourbon is a classic name, but it didn’t quite shine in this blind tasting. The familiar flavors of caramel, vanilla, and oak were present, but the overall experience was unremarkable compared to the competition. It’s a decent pour but didn’t leave a lasting impression.
6th Place: Jim Beam Rye
Utah Price: $19.99
Size: 750 ml
Jim Beam Rye presented a spicier alternative to its bourbon counterpart. The rye spice was prominent, with notes of black pepper and a touch of mint. However, the finish was somewhat harsh, and the overall profile was less balanced, placing it in the middle of the pack.
5th Place: Old Crow
Utah Price: $9.99
Size: 750 ml
Old Crow delivered a simple and straightforward bourbon experience. The nose was mild, with faint hints of vanilla and oak. The flavor was light, leaning more towards the sweet side, but it lacked the body and complexity of the higher-ranked whiskeys. It’s an easy drinker, but not one that stands out.
4th Place: Henry McKenna Bourbon
Utah Price: $14.99
Size: 750 ml
Henry McKenna Bourbon offered a slightly more complex profile with notes of caramel, citrus, and a touch of pepper. However, the finish was somewhat short and dry, preventing it from ranking higher. Still, it’s a good budget option for those seeking a bit more nuance.
3rd Place: Evan Williams Black Label
Utah Price: $17.99
Size: 750 ml
Evan Williams Black Label delivered a balanced mix of sweetness and spice, though it lacked the depth of the top two. The aroma of honey and brown sugar was inviting, and the palate offered a slightly smoky finish. It’s a reliable choice for an everyday whiskey but didn’t quite rise to the occasion in this lineup.
2nd Place: Ancient Age
Utah Price: $15.49
Size: 1000 ml
Ancient Age was a close runner-up with its smooth and approachable taste. The nose offered a blend of sweet corn and light spice, while the palate was soft, with hints of vanilla and oak. It’s a straightforward bourbon that’s easy to drink, making it a solid option for both newcomers and seasoned whiskey drinkers alike.
1st Place: Benchmark Old No 8 Brand
Utah Price: $13.99
Size: 750 ml
Benchmark Old No 8 Brand took the crown, impressing with its bold character. The spicy rye notes mingled with sweet corn, creating a robust and flavorful profile. The finish was pleasantly warm, making this a great choice for those who enjoy a bit more punch in their whiskey.
Final Thoughts
Benchmark Old No 8 proves that you don’t need to break the bank for a quality whiskey, standing out as the top choice for a budget-friendly pour. Ancient Age and Evan Williams Black Lable also offer great value, showing that there are solid options available even at a lower price point.
